I've been involved in the "complete draft" style and the "crit as you go." I really dislike the crit as you go method - A LOT. The last group I worked with that did this I was involved with three years ago. I met with a friend in the group yesterday who told me everyone was still on the same material that they were working three years ago. Personally, I don't mind reading another person's work and giving notes but I do NOT want to see every. single. draft. I also think that it turns into a mentality where people hold each other back from taking the next step, instead spending forever on polishing the work.
no subject
Date: 2012-01-11 08:07 pm (UTC)